Nice City Council: opposition attacks majority over budget orientation debate

Latest News

🇫🇷 Aussi disponible en Français

The budget guidelines for the city of Nice for 2027 sparked heated exchanges during the municipal council on Thursday, November 19. Opposition councillor Julien Picot in particular challenged the use of an additional 40 million euros in borrowing and the announced elimination of 206 positions. The Finance Deputy, Olivier Breuilly, defended the majority’s forecasts and rejected accusations of austerity.

The debate on the finances of the city of Nice led to an exchange between majority and opposition. On the occasion of the presentation of budget guidelines for 2027, Julien Picot, opposition councillor and president of the finance commission, raised several questions about the municipality’s choices.

The opponent notably challenged the use of new borrowing, the revenue forecasts and the announced reduction in municipal staff. Criticisms to which Olivier Breuilly, deputy mayor in charge of Finance, and the mayor Éric Ciotti responded by defending the majority’s spending control strategy.

40 million euros in borrowing and 206 positions cut denounced by the opposition

Julien Picot first questioned the commissioning of a financial audit from a private firm, for an amount of 70,000 euros. The councillor believes that this service did not provide new information about the organization’s situation. “This audit essentially tells us things we already knew”, he declared.

The opponent also regretted that the municipality did not seek expertise from the Regional Court of Accounts for independent expertise. Beyond the cost of the study, Julien Picot questioned its usefulness, suggesting the possibility of a diagnosis intended to prepare the savings program announced by the majority.

On the 2027 budget guidelines, the use of an additional 40 million euros in borrowing was one of the main points of disagreement. This financing must notably cover the work on the Police Headquarters and the installation of air conditioning in schools.

For Julien Picot, this decision does not align with the majority’s stated commitment to reducing debt. The councillor believes that these investments could have been financed through the city’s self-financing capacity. The new borrowing will result, according to his analysis, in higher debt interest and financial charges for the following years.

The revenue forecasts were also questioned. The opposition noted an announced decrease of 34 million euros in actual operating revenues in 2027 compared to 2026. Julien Picot also mentioned more than 41 million euros in losses of tax revenues, to which would be added lower on-street parking revenues. The councillor thus expressed reservations about the accuracy of the assumptions used to build the budget.

Another subject raised during the debate: municipal staff. The announced reduction of 206 civil servant positions raises concerns within the opposition. Julien Picot asks to know which services are affected and the consequences for tasks performed for residents.

“Cutting 206 positions means taking the risk of degrading working conditions for employees and the quality of service provided to the population”, he warned. The councillor also demands clarification on the 60 million euro savings plan announced by the municipality, whose breakdown has not yet been detailed in the elements discussed during the session.

Olivier Breuilly rejects accusations of austerity

In response, Olivier Breuilly contested the criticisms raised by the opposition. The Finance Deputy estimated that the majority’s opposing councillors were developing two distinct arguments: denouncing an austerity policy and challenging the reliability of budget forecasts. “Two oppositions, two speeches, but ultimately one same method: fear. Fear that we will succeed where you have failed”, he said.

The majority councillor notably defended the distinction between spending cuts and degradation of public services. “You systematically confuse spending control with austerity”, he replied to the left-wing councillors.

Olivier Breuilly also contested the idea that the quality of municipal services would depend solely on the number of positions in the budget. “The quality of a public service is not measured only by the number of positions in a table”, he stated.

On financial forecasts, the deputy recalled that the amounts presented corresponded to estimates for the coming year, not to definitive results. “The figures we have presented are forecasts and we do not present them as already achieved results“, he clarified.

The majority thus defends a spending control policy, while the opposition calls for more details on planned savings and their consequences for municipal services.

Subsequently, the mayor Éric Ciotti defended himself against implementing what he advocated during his municipal election campaign: “We wanted to lower taxes and the taxes of Nice residents that you heavily increased indecently (referring to the previous municipal administration represented by Anthony Borré and Philippe Pradal, Editor’s note). You picked the pockets of Nice residents to finance your lifestyle […] From the beginning of our term, we decided to return 52 million euros to Nice residents.”

A fund of 500,000 euros and the situation of the Opera on the agenda

The municipal council also examined the creation of an aid fund of 500,000 euros intended to finance exceptional expenses for security related to demonstrations. The scheme concerns occupants or operators of premises with a storefront facing public space. The conditions for allocation must regulate any aid granted to the professionals concerned.

The situation of the Nice Opera was also addressed during the examination of the 2026 budget adjustment decision. The Left and Ecologists group challenged the majority on financial decisions, while artists have been mobilized for several weeks to obtain a pay increase.

The opposition notably noted a decrease of 100,000 euros in personnel credits and an increase of 351,740 euros in service provision expenses. These budget movements are occurring in a context of labor negotiations underway for eight months.

The councillors also denounced the cancellation of two performances, which reportedly resulted in a loss of 200,000 euros in revenue according to figures mentioned during the session. The group asked the mayor to meet with the artists and respond to their salary demands.

NicePremium is a free, independent local news outlet.
Help us keep going by supporting our work from €5 per month.

Support NicePremium

spot_img
- Sponsorisé -Récupération de DonnèeRécupération de DonnèeRécupération de DonnèeRécupération de Donnèe

Must read

Reportages