We will not comment on the dynamics and chronology of the events, but we cannot remain indifferent to the sight of a photograph showing a police officer in “Robocop” gear pointing his (electrical?) weapon at a striking firefighter (naturally unarmed), or another where another protester is seen on the ground being accosted by several police officers with their batons.
These are frankly unpleasant images because when it comes to violence, whether physical or at least moral, one must wonder if social balance and cohesion are at risk! Police officers and firefighters are both servants of the state, with the same public mission, even if different in application.
The Prefect stated that “Public order prevails over the freedom to demonstrate”… and we will not engage in a nuanced legal battle over the principle of ‘jus variandi in melius re perensa’ (the change of law in case of a more favorable interest).
Yes, “the law is the law,” but isn’t there also discretion in its application? Can we really believe that firefighters, in defending their professional interests through union action, have become a public danger or even thugs?
Isn’t it advisable in such cases to extinguish the fire (if there is one) by showing calm and patience, allowing pedagogy to take precedence over force and repression?
Perhaps the Mayor is right when he claims that, according to regulations, firefighters did not have the right to wear their uniforms during a union demonstration. But in that case, the question arises โ is social cohesion a matter of dress code?
We believe it is essential to demonstrate balance and a sense of responsibility. Carrying out public duties in a democracy should not pit one against another but rather recognize each person’s reasons within a framework that respects everyone’s rights and duties.
“Each for their part and all together, we will solve the problems,” said an old slogan.
Beyond the nostalgia for the good old days, we should be wary of those who think themselves the ‘melior pars’ capable of managing complexity. Because if it were that easy and simple… everyone would know!