This work is a very beautiful evocation of the history of Constantinople and Byzantium. The author shows us the evolution of the Eastern Roman Empire with its refinement and decadence.
The decadence of a civilization is often identified with refined manners and the loss of warrior values. Gilles Martin-Chauffier demonstrates the unfolding of events and the intrigues of the Eastern emperors. The downfall of Byzantium lies within its own institutions.
However, there is a caveat to this remarkable book: the author takes sides with the Ottomans and advocates for Turkey’s entry into Europe. He presents a nearly idyllic view of the Ottomans, justifying the abduction of Christian children in the Ottoman Empire and downplaying the naval Battle of Lepanto. This partisan stance is quite regrettable, and the story of Constantinople suffers, particularly in the final part where the historian gives voice to a supporter of Turkey’s entry into the European Union.
At that point, he is no longer a historian. We respond to him: Let’s see, when Istanbul becomes Constantinople again, the Turks will have demonstrated their willingness to integrate into the European community. But given the current state of affairs in this country, their integration is more than doubtful.
We suggest the author revisits his work and shows a bit more objectivity, the basis of historical and intellectual honesty.
Thierry Jan
